More info on Pietcard cdi boxes, 2013 vs 2041

So I contacted pietcard to clarify some cdi box stuff. Apparently the 2013 does retard and this is what he said:

Hello Mike

Both CDI retard the timing,

The 2013 is until 10.000 RPM

The 2041 is until 16.000 RPM

But this CDI need the correct coil to work good.

Regards,

Fabián Müller

PIETCARD ELECTRÓNICA SRL

Im prying for a little more clarification.

Re: More info on Pietcard cdi boxes, 2013 vs 2041

yeah 2013 does not retard it advances (too much) with the yellow cev coil but it does retard with the red motoplat coil and on treats cdi... looks like eds been right... power is in the coil and the box.

Re: More info on Pietcard cdi boxes, 2013 vs 2041

thanks for contacting them mike!

Re: More info on Pietcard cdi boxes, 2013 vs 2041

Well he states that it does retard, im pretty certain he is stating that you need a "good" external coil.

Re: More info on Pietcard cdi boxes, 2013 vs 2041

I sent another email to clear this up too.

Re: More info on Pietcard cdi boxes, 2013 vs 2041

There made for argentina moped NOT european. So you must hack them.

good look, on trying to clear up the problem but there is no problem just need to test every else combo.

Re: More info on Pietcard cdi boxes, 2013 vs 2041

Origin of build does not seem to be an issue. Minarelli, Zanellas, Carabellas spin the same the same direction and the same stator and flywheel work on all said. I dont get the argument ed? The BRN cylinders are made in argentina for zanellas, right? So with your argument these would not work :)

Re: More info on Pietcard cdi boxes, 2013 vs 2041

There not a racing cdi. I was mistaken so long ago. There a replacement to get rid of the points and condenser.

Re: More info on Pietcard cdi boxes, 2013 vs 2041

Michael Thomas Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> Origin of build does not seem to be an issue.

> Minarelli, Zanellas, Carabellas spin the same the

> same direction and the same stator and flywheel

> work on all said. I dont get the argument ed?

> The BRN cylinders are made in argentina for

> zanellas, right? So with your argument these

> would not work :)

There is no argement. I don't what your coming off like that but let me just say. Use them as need be and adjust them as needed. cheers!

Re: More info on Pietcard cdi boxes, 2013 vs 2041

Its all about the magnetos.

Tell me why the bosch 06 w/2013 cdi package has a curve on the v1's.

You haven't seen my youtube video of this cdi? (edited)

Re: More info on Pietcard cdi boxes, 2013 vs 2041

Indeed, and the yellow pietcard 3003/04 part is listed for zanellas and v1-v2 etc with the cev. Still dont see the argument since my focus on the research is to better the italian stuff since pietcard is not popular with the "other" crowd. Doesnt appear to need any hacking? Just looking for the best box and some clarification before we get to hot and heavy over the 2041. Basically from all of this I want to see if the 2041 would really be much of an improvement over my 2013. Oh, im not jumping on you ed:) Just trying to improve my bike a little.

Re: More info on Pietcard cdi boxes, 2013 vs 2041

Curve advanced or retarded?, im on a crappy work machine so I cant watch. On my 04 with a cev stator it retards... Dunno. It is a company in which I have received a brand new green unit and 2013 box that doesn't work at all so im sure there are some variances in quality.

Re: More info on Pietcard cdi boxes, 2013 vs 2041

2013 is to 10000 rpm does that mean the curve goes dead after 10000 or what? i have a a coil and the 2013 box that im gonna be putting on a 77 reed kit that should spin around that and i'd be real hyped if it didn't just cut out like some of the tomos cdi boxes do...

Re: More info on Pietcard cdi boxes, 2013 vs 2041

Most of the zanella came with motoplat magnetos. I do not know how long the dze or cev was used. I would timing light everything and video it. Just search minarelli v1 peitcard on youtube. Let me know what you think.

Wow, brand new and doesn't work. :(

Re: More info on Pietcard cdi boxes, 2013 vs 2041

Hehe, yeah, got it from a cool ass minarelli dude (wink wink) with some horse trading.

Re: More info on Pietcard cdi boxes, 2013 vs 2041

I can't understand either the original pietcard guy, nor ed. i'm so confused. I don't even have a minarelli anyway so i dunno why i care, or why i'm writing this.

Anyway, good stuff to know, thanks guys

Re: More info on Pietcard cdi boxes, 2013 vs 2041

lol, perfect

Re: More info on Pietcard cdi boxes, 2013 vs 2041

Woot, finally something specific:

Mike, when I say until 10.000 it mean that the CDI can broke up 10.000 RPM.

If your motorcycle work more 10.000 you must to use the CDI 2041 with the correct proper coil.

The proper coil depend the magnetic wheel and the rotating engine.

You can see our webpage in the serie 100.

Any question please tell me.

Sorry for my English

Regards

Fabián Müller

PIETCARD ELECTRÓNICA SRL

Re: More info on Pietcard cdi boxes, 2013 vs 2041

Well ain't that just ducky.

Re: More info on Pietcard cdi boxes, 2013 vs 2041

good to know.

Re: More info on Pietcard cdi boxes, 2013 vs 2041

Thanks for all the info and research. I got a blue one for some reason with 2013 box.looks like I will need the 2041. Brn kit. This whole thing is tearing me apart. I'm running points for break in .f it

Re: More info on Pietcard cdi boxes, 2013 vs 2041

Have you tested the blue one yet? Should test it and take video of the curve. I have one also I need to get time to test and see if has a curve. Different magnetos are going to do different things. Watch the youtube.

Re: More info on Pietcard cdi boxes, 2013 vs 2041

link the youtube video ed...please.

Re: More info on Pietcard cdi boxes, 2013 vs 2041

Re: More info on Pietcard cdi boxes, 2013 vs 2041

that is fucking excellent, especially when i play adele rolling in the deep in the background. I gotta do me a casematch and then i'll be able to see how the 2013 box works with the red/brown coil i got from you and a bosch e50 magneto. I'll be sure to get a video and upload it, but that timing retarding is AWESOME.

Re: More info on Pietcard cdi boxes, 2013 vs 2041

the timing advance/retard on these analog systems is based on the current pulse coming in. The more powerful pulse, the faster the CDI circuit triggers, meaning the faster the engine is spinning, faster magnetisim change, higher magnetic flux, faster spark (more advanced).

this is weighed against the internal components of the circuit (capacitor and inductor) which result in a phase lag as the frequency increases, this makes the spark more retarded.

the two effects are occurring simultaneously in the circuit, and fighting against each other, so having the box work consistently is a delicate electronic balancing act. If one coil has more windings than the originally intended coil, the advance will win because the increase in power is outweighing the lag of the circuit, if you use a less powerful coil the circuit will lag more (generally speaking) because now the capacitor is winning. If you start mixing and matching crazy different boxes and coils that aren't made for each other you will get totally unpredictable results. the only way to find out is doing a lot of testing, or cutting everythign apart and modeling it (very time consuming, but i'm working on doing some of that).

i'm sure pietcard has designed certain boxes to work on certain coils and do certain things, perhaps using the minarelli coil the 2013 will do some retarding, but the bosch coil is too powerful and makes it advance or not retard... the 2041 would have different capacitors and resistors to make the bosch coil work.

without knowing the coil output waveform, the circuit schematic, and doing some modeling/simulation there is no real way of 'knowing' what combinations will work in what way. Even the magnetivity of say, a peugeot flywheel vs a bosch flywheel, will give totally different responses. given the response that pietcard gave, they probably are using 'rule of thumbs' or perhaps the only guy that speaks english has better things to do that explain all that to us.

Re: More info on Pietcard cdi boxes, 2013 vs 2041

I just try different combinations until I find something that works well for my application :)

Re: More info on Pietcard cdi boxes, 2013 vs 2041

also: for awhile i was trying to figure out if i could use a china pocket bike motor CDI on my tomos A55 1 wire ignition (early revival)... the answer is yes, they do work, but the china CDI is so crappy that it advances dramatically after 5000 rpm... this is probably what the stock (bad) tomos ignitions do, and thats probably what the pietcard does, or maybe it just cuts out... ach! need more testing!

Re: More info on Pietcard cdi boxes, 2013 vs 2041

Whose tried what on a morini M1 with the cev 6420 stator?

Re: More info on Pietcard cdi boxes, 2013 vs 2041

You could experiment with the air gap between the shoes of the coil spool and the rotating magnets. Maybe even elongating the slots the attaching screws ride in.

Want to post in this forum? We'd love to have you join the discussion, but first:

Login or Create Account