I never said it wouldn't work? I was just saying that if the guy wants to sell these people are more apt to buy something that was made by someone that knew what they were doing. Just because it has a giant weld on it doesn't mean its stronger? From my experience with welding if it sticks out super far like in the pic it actually means you didn't get very good penetration. I'm not trying to be a dick and am glad that people are taking initiative and making there own parts.