Re: Head to head is the only accurate way.

jamie leonard /
This single post is part of a larger thread. Start from the top or view this post in context.

But you missed some of my points (which I didn't think were silly at all)

1. Averaging out results from different machines means you don't end up proving that ONE moped is more/less efficient than ONE motorcycle - which is all a head to head race would prove. Unless you had several mopeds and several motorcycles.

2. Motorcycles and mopeds have different speeds at which they reach maximum efficiency, and things like idle gas usage would affect them differently. So a lower speed path with lots of stops might favour one machine, whereas a different path would favour another machine - so you'd need to do a few different paths to get any real result (again with different motorcycles and mopeds) This would be the preferred thing I admit, but not likely to happen... whereas just averaging out peoples everyday riding results isn't terribly hard to arrange.

One machine against one other machine will only prove anything for that particular brand compared to another particular brand.... not give any real results for the general machine type. It'd be like having one random person sample a drug from the street and one other person samples another drug... and whomever gets cured first proves the drug works. Doesn't really give any real info.

This single post is part of a larger thread. Start from the top or view this post in context.
Subject Written By Posted
  Mopeds vs motorcyclesTopic by: zxrider zxrider 08/24/01 11:00PM
  Re: Mopeds vs motorcyclesRe: Jessie S. Band Jessie S. Band 08/24/01 11:35PM
  Re: Mopeds vs motorcyclesRe: XBrandon EdgeX XBrandon EdgeX 08/25/01 12:04AM
  Re: Mopeds vs motorcyclesRe: Rick Rick 08/25/01 01:16AM
  A bit overstatedRe: Fred Fred 08/25/01 01:17AM
  Re: A bit overstatedRe: Jamie Leonard Jamie Leonard 08/25/01 03:08PM
  The Efficiency Challenge !Re: The Moped Gawd The Moped Gawd 08/26/01 07:28PM
  Re: The Efficiency Challenge !Re: Wayne Broderick Wayne Broderick 08/26/01 07:42PM
  Re: The Efficiency Challenge !Re: Wayne Broderick Wayne Broderick 08/26/01 07:55PM
  Re: The Efficiency Challenge !Re: Jamie Leonard Jamie Leonard 08/26/01 09:21PM
  Head to head is the only accurate way.Re: Fred Fred 08/26/01 11:17PM
  Re: Head to head is the only accurate way.Re: Jamie Leonard Jamie Leonard 08/27/01 01:20AM
  Head to head is the only accurate way.Re: Fred Fred 08/27/01 03:43PM
  Re: Head to head is the only accurate way.Re: jamie leonard jamie leonard 08/27/01 03:59PM
  Re: The Efficiency Challenge !Re: Ron Brown Ron Brown 08/27/01 01:36PM
  Re: The Efficiency Challenge !Re: jamie leonard jamie leonard 08/27/01 01:45PM
  Re: The Efficiency Challenge !Re: Fred Fred 08/27/01 03:20PM
  Re: The Efficiency Challenge !Re: Ron Brown Ron Brown 08/27/01 06:07PM
  Re: The Efficiency Challenge !Re: gimmyjimmy gimmyjimmy 08/27/01 10:33PM
  Re: The Efficiency Challenge !Re: Ron Brown Ron Brown 08/27/01 01:51PM
  Re: Mopeds vs motorcyclesRe: Jimmy Jimmy 09/20/01 11:03PM
  Re: Mopeds vs motorcyclesRe: TIP TIP 08/25/01 08:30AM
  Re: Mopeds vs motorcyclesRe: Peggy Peggy 08/25/01 11:25AM
  Re: Mopeds vs motorcyclesRe: Jamie Leonard Jamie Leonard 08/25/01 03:12PM
  Re: Mopeds vs motorcyclesRe: Ken Ken 08/25/01 09:39PM
  Poor man's Hot-RoddingRe: Miniengine Miniengine 08/25/01 11:51PM
  Re: Mopeds vs motorcyclesRe: Ron Brown Ron Brown 08/26/01 11:08AM
  Thanks Everyone!Re: zxrider zxrider 08/27/01 07:13PM
  Re: Thanks Everyone!Re: Ron Brown Ron Brown 08/28/01 12:12PM
  Re: Thanks Everyone!Re: Richard King Richard King 08/31/01 01:14AM

Want to post in this forum? We'd love to have you join the discussion, but first:

Login or Create Account